ReallyBadTalk

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Friday, 23 March 2012

Grumbler

Posted on 09:35 by Unknown
I am a grognard.

Like many introduced to roleplaying games in the mid- to late Seventies, I was a wargamer first. I started with board-and-chit games - specifically Avalon Hill's 'Bookcase Games,' starting with Tobruk, and later Third Reich, Squad Leader, Panzer Blitz/Leader, and my favorite to this day, Kingmaker, along with several others - then added metal minis, first learning the 15mm Napoleonics house rules used at my local gaming shop, encased in plastic covers in three-ring binders chained the sandtable in the back of the shop.

Roleplaying games slowly consumed more of my free time; my Starfleet Wars Terran squadron was given away around my sophmore year of high school after I started playing Traveller in 1979, for example. The exception was The Sword and the Flame, which I continued to play through high school, publishing a few issues of a 'zine my senior year for TSatF campaigns on the North-West Frontier; rather than falling by the wayside, my TSatF scenarios spun off a couple of 'Great Game' adventures using Boot Hill, with my 25mm Minifigs Punjab Irregulars serving double-duty with some 1:72 plastic Italeri or Atlantic Pathans.

Mashing up wargames and roleplaying games was pretty common, sometimes by design. GDW specifically integrated Traveller with Mayday, Snapshot, and Striker, of course, and I used the rules from TSR's Divine Right for resolving the clash of fantasy armies in my AD&D campaign.

Much has been written about the wargaming roots of roleplaying games. Personally I'm most often reminded of this history when discussions turn to combat in rpgs. After twelve years away from the hobby, I returned with 3e D&D, and I found myself a bit bumfuzzled by gamers who gushed about how 'tactical' 3e was, with its rules for flanking and attacks of opportunity and so forth.

I was puzzled by this for a couple of reasons. First, many, if not most, of the 'tactical' rules that 3e gamers prattled on about had their origins in AD&D. Second, and more bizarrely from my perspective, so much of what they talked about seemed to have more to do with Magic: The Gathering deck building and little if anything to do with tactics as I understand the word.

Coming into the hobby as a wargamer, I found the combat rules in games like AD&D to be simple and intuitive. Frex, nowhere does AD&D spell out the advantage of placing a rank of pikemen ahead of two ranks of heavy crossbowmen, and from my perspective it wasn't necessary for the rules to do so - the pikemen receive a to-hit and damage bonus for setting their pikes against a charge, and the ranks of crossbowmen alternate their fire, as expected from their 1/2 rate of fire, to maintain a steady barrage of bolts. The rules reward tactical thinking, provided you understand the tactics the rules are designed to reward.

But many gamers who came into the hobby after me were not wargamers. The implicit tactics of the rules were lost on them. Furthermore many learned the game through oral tradition rather than reading the rules in the first place, adding a further remove from the wargaming origins. I never realized until I started sharing experiences with other gamers on bulletin boards how exceptional my high school gaming group was: four of us rotated through the referee's chair, and we each poured through rulebooks like the DMG or Mayday, hunting for obscure rules to spring on one another during our turns behind the screen. The net effect was to give us an intimate familiarity with the rules - what the current jargon calls 'game mastery' - that many of our peers apparently never acquired.

To gamers who didn't grok the implied tactics, combat in early roleplaying games could seem sterile, as I learned from many fans of 3e on my return to gaming. But I noticed that after awhile, the 'tactics' of many roleplaying games came to resemble ordering from a Chinese menu, matching class ability from column A against supernatural ability from column B to get the free bowl of egg drop soup or a side of spring rolls. The real-world tactics that wargames attempt to model was increasingly replaced with dissociated mechanics which primarily reward game rules-knowledge.

Experience with wargames contributed to the differences between characters as well. One of the complaints leveled against early editions of the D&D, frex, is that there is nothing to distinguish two fighters of the same level, yet I never found this to be the case because different players chose to emphasize different tactics. Some players wanted their characters to fight like heavy infantry battling toe-to-toe to break the enemy's line, while others wanted theirs to perform more like skirmishers harassing and wearing down the enemy, and they would equip and play their characters accordingly, so even if they were more-or-less identical mechanically, their tactics and peformance in combat varied consistently during actual play.

Even now if you scratch my roleplayer surface you'll find the wargamer gleaming dully underneath. I can't play a game with automatic weapons without adding in rules for suppressing fire, and the fact that I frequently have to do so is a ridiculously common oversight on the part of game designers - I'm looking at you, d20 Modern. One of the reasons I chose Flashing Blades for my current campaign is that it has rules for throwing sand in an opponent's face and kicking him in the junk as well as trying to stick a rapier in his eye, and not Enhanced Mobility and Elaborate Parry. And I still like to mash up wargames and roleplaying games, like AK-47 Republic with Top Secret and Field of Glory with Flashing Blades - I need to set aside some portion of my disposable income toward building 2mm armies for FoG.

Now you kids get off my lawn, or I'll turn the hose on ya.
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in grognard, miniatures, old man is old, personal, wargames | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Carte de Cassini
    In a post at Built by Gods Long Forgotten describing a clever approach to designing a megadungeon , Lum includes a link to an interactive ve...
  • Everyone Talks About the Weather
    Now someone's finally done something about it. Friend of the blog Bren at RPG Net created a nifty weather table for use with his Hono...
  • Stupid Dice Tricks
    I have mixed feelings about novelty randomisers. Novelty randomisers aren't new to roleplaying games - Crimson Cutlass , for example, u...
  • The Pen and the Sword: The Cavalier in the Yellow Doublet
    He decided to finish the business, although not so hastily that it might work against him. Besides, there was no point in complicating his l...
  • DVR Alert
    If Monday night's The Adventures of Don Juan whetted your appetite for more Errol Flynn, on Thursday Friday see him in his prime when ...
  • Upstairs, Downstairs: The Help, Continued
    Previously I wrote about servants in a cape-and-sword campaign, as seen in the source literature and the rules of a couple of swashbuckling...
  • A Very Special DVR Alert
    On Sunday, 2 December, TCM is showing King Vidor's long-lost 1926 silent classic, Bardelys the Magnificent . This is perhaps the best c...
  • As Promised On This Very Blog
    Sean B at Wine and Savages reviews the All for One: Régime Diabolique setting book for Savage Worlds . And on the strength of his review, I...
  • Meditation on a Visit to a Game Store
    Last Sunday I stopped at Game Empire in Pasadena. First, let me say that Game Empire is what other gaming stores should aspire to be. The r...
  • Graphic Novels Challenge: Belladone
    An assassin takes a shot at Louis XIV, but the ball is deflected by the iron fan of a nearby nun, who with a winsome smile leaps over the s...

Categories

  • -C
  • 1602
  • 1612 (movie)
  • 1650 (game)
  • 7RPGS
  • 7th Sea
  • A Field in England
  • A to Z 2012
  • actual play
  • adventure path
  • Adventure Time
  • Against All Flags
  • Age of Ravens
  • Alain Delon
  • Alatriste
  • Alexander Macris
  • Alexandre Dumas
  • Alice B Woodward
  • All for One Régime Diabolique
  • alt history
  • Amanda Heitler
  • ancien régime
  • Andy Murray. meta
  • animal
  • animation
  • Anthony Hope
  • Arabian Nights
  • art
  • Arturo Pérez-Reverte
  • At Sword's Point (movie)
  • award
  • background
  • Backswords and Bucklers
  • bandwagon jumping
  • baragei
  • Barbaric Frontier
  • Barbie
  • Bardelys the Magnificent
  • Barry Lyndon
  • baseball
  • Batman
  • Bayuca
  • BBC America
  • Beedo
  • Belladone
  • BH 1 Mad Mesa
  • Big Purple
  • Black Vulmea
  • Black Vulmea's Vengeance
  • Blog of Holding
  • blogfest
  • Blogger
  • Blunders on the Danube
  • board game
  • Bob Anderson
  • Bold Pueblo Games
  • Bombshell Miniatures
  • Book Scorpion's Lair
  • books
  • Boot Hill
  • Bren at RPG Net
  • British Isles Traveller Support
  • BryanMD
  • Bushido
  • Caoimhe Ora Snow
  • cape-and-sword
  • Capitan
  • Capitán Alatriste (game)
  • Captain Alatriste
  • Captain Blood (movie)
  • Captain Blood (novel)
  • Captain from Castile
  • Captain Hook
  • Captain Horatio Hornblower
  • Captain Morgan
  • Cara King
  • card game
  • cartography
  • cartoon
  • Cassini map
  • catacombs
  • Catan Junior
  • Cesare Borgia
  • character
  • charity
  • Charles Perrault
  • chase
  • chateau
  • Chill
  • Christopher Columbus
  • Chronicles of Shadow Valley
  • Cinematic
  • comics
  • commercial
  • Condottieri Conflicts
  • conquistadors
  • ConTtessa
  • corsairs
  • cosplay
  • Crimson Cutlass
  • Crossbones
  • CS Forester
  • Cutthroat Island
  • cycling
  • Cyrano de Bergerac
  • d'Artagnan
  • d20
  • d20 Modern
  • d20 Past
  • d20 Pirates
  • Daffy Duck
  • Dangerous Beauty
  • Dangerous Liasons
  • Danny Kaye
  • Dark Dimension
  • David Balfour
  • DC Comics
  • De cape et d'épée
  • DeviantArt
  • Die Another Day
  • disability
  • Disneyland
  • diversity
  • Douglas Fairbanks Sr
  • Dr Rotwang
  • Drama Dice and Damsons
  • Dreams of the Lich House
  • DriveThruRPG
  • duel
  • Duelist (prestige class)
  • Dungeons and Dragons
  • Dynamite Entertainment
  • Dynasties and Demagogues
  • ECW
  • El Cazador
  • Ellen Kushner
  • Emmy Rossum
  • en français
  • En Garde (game)
  • EN World
  • endgame
  • Eric Treasure
  • errata
  • Errol Flynn
  • Ethan Skemp
  • Exchange of Realities
  • Fabled Lands
  • fantasy
  • festival
  • Fist Full of Seamen
  • Flashing Blades
  • Flashman
  • FLGS
  • Flying Swordsmen
  • Frank C Papé
  • Frank Frazetta
  • Frank Schoonover
  • Frankenstein
  • Fred Funcken
  • FXR
  • Game Empire
  • game fiction
  • game style quiz
  • games
  • Gary Gygax
  • George Waymouth
  • Gloire
  • Gonsalvo
  • gospel
  • Graham Bottley
  • Graphic Novels Challenge
  • grognard
  • gun control
  • GURPS
  • Hack and Slash
  • Hamlet (1996 movie)
  • Han shot first
  • Harold Lamb
  • heads up
  • Hearts
  • Heidi Brühl
  • Helen Hunt Jackson
  • Hendybadger
  • hero points
  • HeroPress
  • Hidden in Shadows
  • High Seas
  • historical roleplaying
  • history
  • hobby
  • holiday
  • Honor + Intrigue
  • Horatio Hornblower
  • Horrible Histories
  • horror
  • house rules
  • Howard Pyle
  • Howling Tower
  • humor
  • I Waste the Buddha With My Crossbow
  • ice hockey
  • Iceland
  • immersion
  • improv
  • Inca
  • Infernal Sorceress
  • International Catacomb Society
  • interview
  • IntWisCha
  • Ivanhoe
  • Jack Sparrow
  • James Bone 007 Roleplaying Game
  • James Fenimore Cooper
  • James Mason
  • Jean Laffite
  • Jedediah
  • Jeff Black
  • Jeff Rients
  • Jeffrey Catherine Jones
  • jeu de palme
  • JF
  • John Gilbert
  • John Paul Jones
  • John Sayles
  • Jules Verne
  • Khlit the Cossack
  • Kickstarter
  • Kingdom of Saguenay
  • komradebob
  • La Fille de d'Artagnan
  • lazy git
  • Le Ballet de l'Acier
  • Le Bossu
  • Legends of the High Seas
  • LEGO
  • linear adventure
  • literature
  • location
  • Lone Star
  • Long John Silver (novel)
  • Lord Dunsany
  • Lord Gwydion
  • Lord Nelson
  • Los Nikis
  • Lowell Francis
  • M.P.
  • magic
  • magic items
  • map
  • maritime
  • Mark Twain
  • martial arts
  • Marvel Comics
  • Masks
  • Maureen O'Hara
  • Mayan non-Apocalypse
  • Mead Schaeffer
  • Mediterranean
  • Melan
  • meta
  • Michael Crichton
  • Mike Mornard
  • milestone
  • miniatures
  • Mitch Williamson
  • Mithril Wisdom
  • Molière
  • Moonfleet
  • movie
  • music
  • musketeer
  • Mysterious Island
  • Mythic Game Master Emulator
  • Mythic Role Playing
  • names
  • Nasruddin
  • Natalie Dormer
  • Nate Christen
  • navel gazing
  • nc wyeth
  • NC Wyeth's Pilgrims
  • New France
  • Nick
  • npcs
  • NPS
  • Obsidian Portal
  • Odie
  • OEF
  • off the shelf
  • off-hand weapon
  • old man is old
  • Old Stuff Day
  • Order of the d30
  • Oriental
  • Osprey Publishing
  • OSR
  • Ottavia Piccolo
  • Paris
  • Pathfinder
  • Paul
  • PDQ#
  • perdustin
  • personal
  • Peter and Wendy
  • phoning it in
  • Pierre Alary
  • pike-and-shot
  • pilgrims
  • pirate
  • Pirate Latitudes
  • Pirates of the Caribbean Curse of the Black Peal
  • Pirates of the Caribbean On Stranger Tides
  • Pirates of Tripoli
  • playstyle
  • poetry
  • points of light
  • politics
  • pulps
  • Puss in Boots
  • QUAGS
  • Quickly Quietly Carefully
  • Rafael Sabatini
  • Raiders of the Seven Seas
  • Ramona
  • random
  • random. Mediterranean
  • rant
  • Raphael Sabatini
  • Ravyn
  • Ray Harryhausen
  • real life can be a pain in the ass
  • reenactors
  • refereeing
  • Regency
  • REH
  • reply
  • resolutions
  • Restoration
  • review
  • rewards
  • Richard the Lionheart
  • Rip Van Winkle
  • Rob Roy
  • Robert E Howard
  • Robert Louis Stevenson
  • Robert Newton
  • Robert Taylor
  • Robin Hood
  • Robin Laws
  • Robinson Crusoe
  • Robots and Rapiers
  • Rochefort
  • roleplaying
  • roleplaying games
  • Rome
  • Romeo and Juliet
  • Rory's Story Cubes
  • Royal Flash
  • RPG Blog Carnival
  • rpg history
  • RPG Stuff (blog)
  • RPGBA
  • rules
  • Ruritania
  • Saint Patrick's Day
  • sale
  • samurai
  • Samurai Heaven and Earth
  • sandbox
  • Sandy Hook shooting
  • Santa Claus
  • Sanxesta
  • SAR
  • Savage Worlds
  • save or die
  • Save Vs. Dragon
  • Scallywags
  • Scaramouche
  • Sean B
  • Semper Initiativus Unum
  • setting
  • sexism
  • shields
  • ship
  • siegecraft
  • Sinbad
  • SirJarva
  • social contract
  • social sandbox
  • social standing
  • solo
  • Solo Nexus
  • Solomon Kane
  • Sophie Marceau
  • Source of the Nile
  • Spacejacking
  • Spanish Fury
  • stage fighting
  • Stanley J Weyman
  • Star Wars
  • Steve Winter
  • Stewart Granger
  • story games
  • Super-Team Family
  • Swashbuckler (Jolly Roger game)
  • Swashbuckler (Yaquinto game)
  • swashbuckling
  • swashbuckling and sorcery
  • sword
  • Swords of the Red Brotherhood
  • Swordspoint
  • Swordswomen of the Silver Screen
  • Talk Like a Pirate Day
  • Taras Bulba
  • Tartuffe
  • Tavern Cards
  • TCM
  • Te Deum pour un massacre
  • Telecanter
  • Telecanter's Receding Rules
  • television
  • Tenkar's Tavern
  • tennis
  • Tercio Creativo
  • The 13th Warrior
  • The 9Qs
  • The Admiral's Ghost
  • The Adventures of Don Juan
  • The Adventures of Robin Hood
  • The Adventures of Sindbad
  • the Batman
  • The Black Arrow
  • The Black Buccaneer
  • The Black Swan
  • The Borgias
  • The Boy's King Arthur
  • The Buccaneer
  • The Business of War
  • The Cavalier in the Yellow Doublet
  • The Court Jester
  • The Courtship of Miles Standish
  • The Crimson Pirate
  • The Crown and the Ring
  • The Deerslayer
  • The Deluge
  • The Dragon's Flagon
  • The Duelists
  • The Dungeon Dozen
  • The Escapist
  • The Golden Voyage of Sinbad
  • The Isle of Pirate's Doom
  • The Justice of the Duke
  • The Lady and the Bandit
  • The Lion in Winter
  • The Mark of Zorro (1920)
  • The Mark of Zorro (1940)
  • The Mask of Zorro
  • The Master of Ballantrae (movie)
  • The Master of Ballantrae (novel)
  • The Mysterious Stranger
  • The Other Side
  • The Pen and the Sword
  • The Perfect Captain
  • The Phantom of the Opera
  • The Princess Bride
  • The Prisoner of Zenda
  • The Queen's Cavaliers
  • The Russian Storybook
  • The Savage AfterWorld
  • The Scarlet Cockerel
  • The Scarlet Pimpernel (1982 movie)
  • The Scarlet Pumpernickel
  • The Scottish Chiefs
  • The Sea Hawk
  • The Sea-Hawk
  • The Shadow of the Vulture
  • The Spanish Main
  • The Swordsman of Siena
  • The Thief of Bagdad
  • The Three Musketeers
  • The Three Musketeers (novel)
  • The Three Musketeers (Paul WS Andersen)
  • The Three Musketeers (RIchard Lester)
  • The Three Musketeers (Rowland Lee)
  • The Tudors
  • The Usual Suspects
  • The White Company
  • The World of Music
  • theatre
  • theRPGsite
  • Thoul's Paradise
  • Tim Brannan
  • Tim Snider
  • Tiny Solitary Soldiers
  • Top Secret
  • Toshiro Mifune
  • Tour de France
  • Traveller
  • Treasure Island
  • Treasure Island (1934)
  • Troll in the Corner
  • Trollsmyth
  • ttfn
  • TV Tropes
  • Twenty Years After
  • Twitter
  • Tyrone Power
  • Under the Red Robe
  • Universal Studios
  • Vaesen
  • Valley of the Giants
  • vanity
  • Vatel
  • veil of ignorance
  • Very Civile Actions
  • video
  • video game
  • Vikings
  • W Heath Robinson
  • Walter Paget
  • War and Game (blog)
  • wargames
  • Warren W Baumgartner
  • Warrior Pursuits
  • Wars of Louis Quatorze (blog)
  • Wayne R
  • Westward Ho
  • what shite
  • wiki
  • William Hobbs
  • Wimbledon
  • Wine and Savages
  • World of Music
  • world-building
  • Zak S
  • Zorro
  • Zorro (1974)

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (157)
    • ►  September (15)
    • ►  August (13)
    • ►  July (11)
    • ►  June (24)
    • ►  May (21)
    • ►  April (4)
    • ►  March (18)
    • ►  February (22)
    • ►  January (29)
  • ▼  2012 (343)
    • ►  December (32)
    • ►  November (34)
    • ►  October (27)
    • ►  September (21)
    • ►  August (33)
    • ►  July (29)
    • ►  June (28)
    • ►  May (31)
    • ►  April (34)
    • ▼  March (39)
      • The Nevers Thrust
      • More Pirate Skirmishings
      • You Never Forget Your First
      • Off the Shelf: Atlases
      • Wednesday Wyeth
      • DVR Alert
      • O Death, Where Is Thy Sting?
      • More on En Garde!
      • Cinematic: Dangerous Beauty
      • Grumbler
      • Prepare the Fleet
      • Tossing the Gauntlet
      • Wednesday Wyeth
      • Level Appropriate
      • Cinematic: The Spanish Main
      • Non-Player Characters and Conventional Wisdom
      • Crouching Fighter, Hidden Wizard
      • Phoning It In Phriday
      • Honor + Intrigue Campaign Wiki at Obsidian Portal
      • Wednesday Wyeth
      • Playing With History
      • If You Rolled a Seventeen . . .
      • Take It On the Run
      • Cinematic: Alatriste
      • This Field of Honor
      • GMs Day Sale Haul
      • Fun With Blogger Captchas
      • We Shall Doubtless Meet Some Adventure
      • Wednesday Wyeth
      • Solo
      • Another Historic Map Resource
      • No. Appearing 30-500
      • Vaesen
      • Swashbuckling the Paizo Way
      • Cinematic: Romeo and Juliet
      • Carte de Cassini
      • Using Mythic Game Master Emulator as a refereeing ...
      • GMs Day Sale at DriveThruRPG
      • Nothing Is Unobtainable to the Sword
    • ►  February (29)
    • ►  January (6)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile