ReallyBadTalk

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Thursday, 5 April 2012

E is for Exegesis

Posted on 18:57 by Unknown
Roleplaying gamers have a sometimes contentious relationship with the rules of our games.

The rules for a roleplaying game may only number a handful of paragraphs, or run to literally thousands of pages across scores of books. Gamers refer to games as 'light' or 'heavy' depending on their perceived complexity. We draw distinctions between 'crunch' - the rules that determine how actions are resolved - and 'fluff - the descriptive text of the game and the game-world.

Even with all of this attention to the rules, roleplaying games, particularly complex games with many pages of rules, frequently require judgement calls in how the rules are applied. For example, the third edition of Dungeons and Dragons offered players the opportunity to play a magically awakened (intelligent) animal as a character. Years ago, I posed a question based on the idea of playing a knight's awakened warhorse. What happens if the warhouse character tries to climb a sheer cliff? Is the action resolved by rolling a Climb skill check for the hourse as with any other character? Does the horse suffer a penalty to climbing because of his equine body? Or is it simply impossible for the horse to climb a cliff at all?

The answer, according to the rules, was all of the above.

The precursor to roleplaying games was the wargame, and since the 19th century wargames often included a referee or umpire, a neutral third party whose role is to determine the success or failure of moves made by the players and resolve conflicts that arise from the application of the rules to the players' moves. This concept was adopted for roleplaying games very early in their history, of a referee or judge or game master - or more fancifully Dungeon Master, Administrator, Watcher, or Hollyhock God - as, among other things, the final arbiter of questions that arose from the rules.

This is not the only solution to the often-fractious question of WHO DECIDES? in roleplaying games. Early games like En Garde! and Boot Hill could be played without a referee, relying on consensus among the players over questions that arose during the game; later games expanded on this consensus approach by adding specific rules about how consensus would be acheived, or, if interpretation of the rules was vested in an individual, how that person's judgement could be reviewed and overridden.

But the traditional method, of a referee or game master as final arbiter, remains the most common.

So referees necessarily become familiar with the rules.

I found myself poring over the rules of Flashing Blades following our last game-day, for a hole I discovered in the rules some time ago came up in play. In FB, characters in combat may take two normal actions or one long action each turn; for example, a character might choose to thrust and parry (two normal actions) or lunge (one long action). If a character is stunned, then in the following round the character loses one normal action and may not take a long action.

With me so far?

So during our last game-day, one of the non-player characters in a duel was stunned by an attack - I determined in the following round that his one action would be to parry the likely attacks from the player character. The player, seeing the opportunity to take advantage of the stun, decided to attack and counter; a counter is akin to a riposte, turning a parry into an attack.

Except there was no attack for the player to counter, so per the rules this was a wasted action. According to the rules, the only way to get two fencing attacks per round is to attack and counter, regardless if an opponent is stunned or not. Despite the fact that the non-player character was stunned, the player's character could not gain an advantage.

As the referee for the game, my ruling at the time was to let the rules as-written stand, with the promise that I would revisit the subject. Sitting down with the rules, I searched to discern the intent behind the rule as-written. Was this really a hole, or was I just failing to understand the design intent? What aspect of fencing was this intended to simulate? How could I explain this in terms of what the characters would experience in the game-world?

The big question in my mind, is, does allowing a second attack against a stunned opponnent confer too much of an advantage? For example, a character can fire two pistols in a round, so two fencing attacks didn't seem unreasonable when limited to stunned opponents. A character can parry more than one attack in a round with the parry action, and it takes two stuns to make a character helpless in the following round.

Putting all of this together, it makes sense that a character can attack a stunned character twice, and thus another house rule - a rule specific to our campaign - gets added to the lexicon.

Years ago I listend to a rabbi explaining midrash, the interpretation of Torah, to understand the motivations and meaning behind the stories told in the sacred texts, and I was struck by the secular similarity to referees interpreting the sometimes Byzantine rules of tabletop roleplaying games. Specifically, midrash reminded me of that example of that horse trying to get up the cliff, where three different answers found in the rules were all correct, subject to the referee making the interpretation. In one campaign, the horse is able to surge up the cliff, sparks flying from its hooves, while in another, a horse would be forced to find another way around like a horse that we would expect in our own mudane world.

It may seem like having multiple interpretations of the same text is a failure on the part of the system, and their are many games who argue exactly that when asked. But each of those answers gives the campaign played by the referee and the players a distinctive feel, in the same way that rabbis have written different midrashim to understand the implications of a particular passage of Torah.

Exegesis is the search for the truth of a text, but referees may arrive at multiple truths from the text of the game's rules.

And that's a good thing.
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in A to Z 2012, Flashing Blades, refereeing | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Carte de Cassini
    In a post at Built by Gods Long Forgotten describing a clever approach to designing a megadungeon , Lum includes a link to an interactive ve...
  • Everyone Talks About the Weather
    Now someone's finally done something about it. Friend of the blog Bren at RPG Net created a nifty weather table for use with his Hono...
  • Stupid Dice Tricks
    I have mixed feelings about novelty randomisers. Novelty randomisers aren't new to roleplaying games - Crimson Cutlass , for example, u...
  • The Pen and the Sword: The Cavalier in the Yellow Doublet
    He decided to finish the business, although not so hastily that it might work against him. Besides, there was no point in complicating his l...
  • DVR Alert
    If Monday night's The Adventures of Don Juan whetted your appetite for more Errol Flynn, on Thursday Friday see him in his prime when ...
  • Upstairs, Downstairs: The Help, Continued
    Previously I wrote about servants in a cape-and-sword campaign, as seen in the source literature and the rules of a couple of swashbuckling...
  • A Very Special DVR Alert
    On Sunday, 2 December, TCM is showing King Vidor's long-lost 1926 silent classic, Bardelys the Magnificent . This is perhaps the best c...
  • As Promised On This Very Blog
    Sean B at Wine and Savages reviews the All for One: Régime Diabolique setting book for Savage Worlds . And on the strength of his review, I...
  • Meditation on a Visit to a Game Store
    Last Sunday I stopped at Game Empire in Pasadena. First, let me say that Game Empire is what other gaming stores should aspire to be. The r...
  • Graphic Novels Challenge: Belladone
    An assassin takes a shot at Louis XIV, but the ball is deflected by the iron fan of a nearby nun, who with a winsome smile leaps over the s...

Categories

  • -C
  • 1602
  • 1612 (movie)
  • 1650 (game)
  • 7RPGS
  • 7th Sea
  • A Field in England
  • A to Z 2012
  • actual play
  • adventure path
  • Adventure Time
  • Against All Flags
  • Age of Ravens
  • Alain Delon
  • Alatriste
  • Alexander Macris
  • Alexandre Dumas
  • Alice B Woodward
  • All for One Régime Diabolique
  • alt history
  • Amanda Heitler
  • ancien régime
  • Andy Murray. meta
  • animal
  • animation
  • Anthony Hope
  • Arabian Nights
  • art
  • Arturo Pérez-Reverte
  • At Sword's Point (movie)
  • award
  • background
  • Backswords and Bucklers
  • bandwagon jumping
  • baragei
  • Barbaric Frontier
  • Barbie
  • Bardelys the Magnificent
  • Barry Lyndon
  • baseball
  • Batman
  • Bayuca
  • BBC America
  • Beedo
  • Belladone
  • BH 1 Mad Mesa
  • Big Purple
  • Black Vulmea
  • Black Vulmea's Vengeance
  • Blog of Holding
  • blogfest
  • Blogger
  • Blunders on the Danube
  • board game
  • Bob Anderson
  • Bold Pueblo Games
  • Bombshell Miniatures
  • Book Scorpion's Lair
  • books
  • Boot Hill
  • Bren at RPG Net
  • British Isles Traveller Support
  • BryanMD
  • Bushido
  • Caoimhe Ora Snow
  • cape-and-sword
  • Capitan
  • Capitán Alatriste (game)
  • Captain Alatriste
  • Captain Blood (movie)
  • Captain Blood (novel)
  • Captain from Castile
  • Captain Hook
  • Captain Horatio Hornblower
  • Captain Morgan
  • Cara King
  • card game
  • cartography
  • cartoon
  • Cassini map
  • catacombs
  • Catan Junior
  • Cesare Borgia
  • character
  • charity
  • Charles Perrault
  • chase
  • chateau
  • Chill
  • Christopher Columbus
  • Chronicles of Shadow Valley
  • Cinematic
  • comics
  • commercial
  • Condottieri Conflicts
  • conquistadors
  • ConTtessa
  • corsairs
  • cosplay
  • Crimson Cutlass
  • Crossbones
  • CS Forester
  • Cutthroat Island
  • cycling
  • Cyrano de Bergerac
  • d'Artagnan
  • d20
  • d20 Modern
  • d20 Past
  • d20 Pirates
  • Daffy Duck
  • Dangerous Beauty
  • Dangerous Liasons
  • Danny Kaye
  • Dark Dimension
  • David Balfour
  • DC Comics
  • De cape et d'épée
  • DeviantArt
  • Die Another Day
  • disability
  • Disneyland
  • diversity
  • Douglas Fairbanks Sr
  • Dr Rotwang
  • Drama Dice and Damsons
  • Dreams of the Lich House
  • DriveThruRPG
  • duel
  • Duelist (prestige class)
  • Dungeons and Dragons
  • Dynamite Entertainment
  • Dynasties and Demagogues
  • ECW
  • El Cazador
  • Ellen Kushner
  • Emmy Rossum
  • en français
  • En Garde (game)
  • EN World
  • endgame
  • Eric Treasure
  • errata
  • Errol Flynn
  • Ethan Skemp
  • Exchange of Realities
  • Fabled Lands
  • fantasy
  • festival
  • Fist Full of Seamen
  • Flashing Blades
  • Flashman
  • FLGS
  • Flying Swordsmen
  • Frank C Papé
  • Frank Frazetta
  • Frank Schoonover
  • Frankenstein
  • Fred Funcken
  • FXR
  • Game Empire
  • game fiction
  • game style quiz
  • games
  • Gary Gygax
  • George Waymouth
  • Gloire
  • Gonsalvo
  • gospel
  • Graham Bottley
  • Graphic Novels Challenge
  • grognard
  • gun control
  • GURPS
  • Hack and Slash
  • Hamlet (1996 movie)
  • Han shot first
  • Harold Lamb
  • heads up
  • Hearts
  • Heidi Brühl
  • Helen Hunt Jackson
  • Hendybadger
  • hero points
  • HeroPress
  • Hidden in Shadows
  • High Seas
  • historical roleplaying
  • history
  • hobby
  • holiday
  • Honor + Intrigue
  • Horatio Hornblower
  • Horrible Histories
  • horror
  • house rules
  • Howard Pyle
  • Howling Tower
  • humor
  • I Waste the Buddha With My Crossbow
  • ice hockey
  • Iceland
  • immersion
  • improv
  • Inca
  • Infernal Sorceress
  • International Catacomb Society
  • interview
  • IntWisCha
  • Ivanhoe
  • Jack Sparrow
  • James Bone 007 Roleplaying Game
  • James Fenimore Cooper
  • James Mason
  • Jean Laffite
  • Jedediah
  • Jeff Black
  • Jeff Rients
  • Jeffrey Catherine Jones
  • jeu de palme
  • JF
  • John Gilbert
  • John Paul Jones
  • John Sayles
  • Jules Verne
  • Khlit the Cossack
  • Kickstarter
  • Kingdom of Saguenay
  • komradebob
  • La Fille de d'Artagnan
  • lazy git
  • Le Ballet de l'Acier
  • Le Bossu
  • Legends of the High Seas
  • LEGO
  • linear adventure
  • literature
  • location
  • Lone Star
  • Long John Silver (novel)
  • Lord Dunsany
  • Lord Gwydion
  • Lord Nelson
  • Los Nikis
  • Lowell Francis
  • M.P.
  • magic
  • magic items
  • map
  • maritime
  • Mark Twain
  • martial arts
  • Marvel Comics
  • Masks
  • Maureen O'Hara
  • Mayan non-Apocalypse
  • Mead Schaeffer
  • Mediterranean
  • Melan
  • meta
  • Michael Crichton
  • Mike Mornard
  • milestone
  • miniatures
  • Mitch Williamson
  • Mithril Wisdom
  • Molière
  • Moonfleet
  • movie
  • music
  • musketeer
  • Mysterious Island
  • Mythic Game Master Emulator
  • Mythic Role Playing
  • names
  • Nasruddin
  • Natalie Dormer
  • Nate Christen
  • navel gazing
  • nc wyeth
  • NC Wyeth's Pilgrims
  • New France
  • Nick
  • npcs
  • NPS
  • Obsidian Portal
  • Odie
  • OEF
  • off the shelf
  • off-hand weapon
  • old man is old
  • Old Stuff Day
  • Order of the d30
  • Oriental
  • Osprey Publishing
  • OSR
  • Ottavia Piccolo
  • Paris
  • Pathfinder
  • Paul
  • PDQ#
  • perdustin
  • personal
  • Peter and Wendy
  • phoning it in
  • Pierre Alary
  • pike-and-shot
  • pilgrims
  • pirate
  • Pirate Latitudes
  • Pirates of the Caribbean Curse of the Black Peal
  • Pirates of the Caribbean On Stranger Tides
  • Pirates of Tripoli
  • playstyle
  • poetry
  • points of light
  • politics
  • pulps
  • Puss in Boots
  • QUAGS
  • Quickly Quietly Carefully
  • Rafael Sabatini
  • Raiders of the Seven Seas
  • Ramona
  • random
  • random. Mediterranean
  • rant
  • Raphael Sabatini
  • Ravyn
  • Ray Harryhausen
  • real life can be a pain in the ass
  • reenactors
  • refereeing
  • Regency
  • REH
  • reply
  • resolutions
  • Restoration
  • review
  • rewards
  • Richard the Lionheart
  • Rip Van Winkle
  • Rob Roy
  • Robert E Howard
  • Robert Louis Stevenson
  • Robert Newton
  • Robert Taylor
  • Robin Hood
  • Robin Laws
  • Robinson Crusoe
  • Robots and Rapiers
  • Rochefort
  • roleplaying
  • roleplaying games
  • Rome
  • Romeo and Juliet
  • Rory's Story Cubes
  • Royal Flash
  • RPG Blog Carnival
  • rpg history
  • RPG Stuff (blog)
  • RPGBA
  • rules
  • Ruritania
  • Saint Patrick's Day
  • sale
  • samurai
  • Samurai Heaven and Earth
  • sandbox
  • Sandy Hook shooting
  • Santa Claus
  • Sanxesta
  • SAR
  • Savage Worlds
  • save or die
  • Save Vs. Dragon
  • Scallywags
  • Scaramouche
  • Sean B
  • Semper Initiativus Unum
  • setting
  • sexism
  • shields
  • ship
  • siegecraft
  • Sinbad
  • SirJarva
  • social contract
  • social sandbox
  • social standing
  • solo
  • Solo Nexus
  • Solomon Kane
  • Sophie Marceau
  • Source of the Nile
  • Spacejacking
  • Spanish Fury
  • stage fighting
  • Stanley J Weyman
  • Star Wars
  • Steve Winter
  • Stewart Granger
  • story games
  • Super-Team Family
  • Swashbuckler (Jolly Roger game)
  • Swashbuckler (Yaquinto game)
  • swashbuckling
  • swashbuckling and sorcery
  • sword
  • Swords of the Red Brotherhood
  • Swordspoint
  • Swordswomen of the Silver Screen
  • Talk Like a Pirate Day
  • Taras Bulba
  • Tartuffe
  • Tavern Cards
  • TCM
  • Te Deum pour un massacre
  • Telecanter
  • Telecanter's Receding Rules
  • television
  • Tenkar's Tavern
  • tennis
  • Tercio Creativo
  • The 13th Warrior
  • The 9Qs
  • The Admiral's Ghost
  • The Adventures of Don Juan
  • The Adventures of Robin Hood
  • The Adventures of Sindbad
  • the Batman
  • The Black Arrow
  • The Black Buccaneer
  • The Black Swan
  • The Borgias
  • The Boy's King Arthur
  • The Buccaneer
  • The Business of War
  • The Cavalier in the Yellow Doublet
  • The Court Jester
  • The Courtship of Miles Standish
  • The Crimson Pirate
  • The Crown and the Ring
  • The Deerslayer
  • The Deluge
  • The Dragon's Flagon
  • The Duelists
  • The Dungeon Dozen
  • The Escapist
  • The Golden Voyage of Sinbad
  • The Isle of Pirate's Doom
  • The Justice of the Duke
  • The Lady and the Bandit
  • The Lion in Winter
  • The Mark of Zorro (1920)
  • The Mark of Zorro (1940)
  • The Mask of Zorro
  • The Master of Ballantrae (movie)
  • The Master of Ballantrae (novel)
  • The Mysterious Stranger
  • The Other Side
  • The Pen and the Sword
  • The Perfect Captain
  • The Phantom of the Opera
  • The Princess Bride
  • The Prisoner of Zenda
  • The Queen's Cavaliers
  • The Russian Storybook
  • The Savage AfterWorld
  • The Scarlet Cockerel
  • The Scarlet Pimpernel (1982 movie)
  • The Scarlet Pumpernickel
  • The Scottish Chiefs
  • The Sea Hawk
  • The Sea-Hawk
  • The Shadow of the Vulture
  • The Spanish Main
  • The Swordsman of Siena
  • The Thief of Bagdad
  • The Three Musketeers
  • The Three Musketeers (novel)
  • The Three Musketeers (Paul WS Andersen)
  • The Three Musketeers (RIchard Lester)
  • The Three Musketeers (Rowland Lee)
  • The Tudors
  • The Usual Suspects
  • The White Company
  • The World of Music
  • theatre
  • theRPGsite
  • Thoul's Paradise
  • Tim Brannan
  • Tim Snider
  • Tiny Solitary Soldiers
  • Top Secret
  • Toshiro Mifune
  • Tour de France
  • Traveller
  • Treasure Island
  • Treasure Island (1934)
  • Troll in the Corner
  • Trollsmyth
  • ttfn
  • TV Tropes
  • Twenty Years After
  • Twitter
  • Tyrone Power
  • Under the Red Robe
  • Universal Studios
  • Vaesen
  • Valley of the Giants
  • vanity
  • Vatel
  • veil of ignorance
  • Very Civile Actions
  • video
  • video game
  • Vikings
  • W Heath Robinson
  • Walter Paget
  • War and Game (blog)
  • wargames
  • Warren W Baumgartner
  • Warrior Pursuits
  • Wars of Louis Quatorze (blog)
  • Wayne R
  • Westward Ho
  • what shite
  • wiki
  • William Hobbs
  • Wimbledon
  • Wine and Savages
  • World of Music
  • world-building
  • Zak S
  • Zorro
  • Zorro (1974)

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (157)
    • ►  September (15)
    • ►  August (13)
    • ►  July (11)
    • ►  June (24)
    • ►  May (21)
    • ►  April (4)
    • ►  March (18)
    • ►  February (22)
    • ►  January (29)
  • ▼  2012 (343)
    • ►  December (32)
    • ►  November (34)
    • ►  October (27)
    • ►  September (21)
    • ►  August (33)
    • ►  July (29)
    • ►  June (28)
    • ►  May (31)
    • ▼  April (34)
      • Z is for Zorro
      • Y is for Yurt
      • Cinematic: Royal Flash
      • X is for Xiphos
      • W is for Wacky
      • V is for Vikings
      • U is for Unbuilt
      • T is for Tartuffe
      • S is for Serendipity
      • Cinematic: The 13th Warrior
      • R is for Recap
      • Q is for Quixotic
      • P is for Pirates
      • O is for Other
      • N is for Networked
      • Cinematic: Die Another Day
      • M is for Musketeers!
      • L is for Location
      • L is for Lackey
      • L is for Lighthouse
      • K is for KIA
      • J is for Joust
      • I is for Imagineering
      • H is for Honor
      • Cinematic: Against All Flags
      • Down to the Sea in Ships
      • G is for Giants
      • F is for Field of Honor
      • E is for Encounter
      • E is for Exegesis
      • D is for Doubloons
      • C is for Challenge
      • B is for Buckler
      • A is for Animation
    • ►  March (39)
    • ►  February (29)
    • ►  January (6)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile